Mushroom Dumplings with Ginger and Shiitake Broth

 

Each month Simone at Jungle Frog Cooking hosts a Donna Hay photography and styling challenge. The goal of the challenge is to try to reproduce an image from Donna Hay magazine and to learn and have some fun along the way.  I’ve always loved seeing everyone’s submissions and this month the challenge was to reproduce the Mushroom Dumplings with Ginger and Shiitake Broth photo from the Autumn 2012 edition. So I finally decided I’d have a go myself, especially considering the main ingredient is mushrooms, which you all know I adore.

Donna Hay Photography & Styling Challenge - Mushroom Dumplings with Ginger and Shiitake Broth

The main goal of participating in this challenge for me is to learn more about food photography, and who better to learn from than the amazingly talented team that work on Donna Hay magazine. The original photo, above, which appeared in the magazine was taken by Chris Court, and on the surface the styling is very clean and simple, which Donna is synonymous with, but reproducing the same results at home I found to be a challenge.
Firstly I didn’t have a background similar to what was used in the photo. I tried using the back of a large stainless steel tray I had but the tray was too small, and in lieu of purchasing a background just for this photo I decided to use a grey tablecloth I had. Secondly I couldn’t find the micro herbs used as garnish so went with a garnish of coriander and chilli. Finally, I found it difficult to position the dumplings in a similar way to the photo. By the time I’d moved them a few times my dumplings started to fall apart and some of the filling leeched into the broth. In the end I had to use some of the shiitakes in the broth to keep the dumplings together. Nevertheless I decided to proceed because after all the goal is to learn.

 

So, here is my version below. To be honest, I’m not very happy with it, but I certainly did learn along the way. Anyway, what do you think of my attempt?

Mushroom Dumplings with Ginger and Shiitake Broth | from http://www.ledelicieux.com

Finally, I decided to take some photos of the broth the way I would style it.

Mushroom Dumpling Soup with Ginger and Shitake Broth

All in all this was a fun challenge, and I look forward to participating again in the future.

So how does the soup taste? Fantastic actually, although I had to change the original recipe a little to make it vegetarian and also due to the lack of availability of some ingredients.  Even Troy – who before we met hated mushrooms and but has come to enjoy them over the years since we’ve been together, although his tolerance for anything too mushroomy is limited – loved it. I will definitely make this Mushroom Dumplings with Ginger and Shiitake Broth recipe again. However I will make a few changes to suit our tastes. Specifically the dumplings, which while I found cute in their pyramid shape they were too big to eat gracefully. I think next time I will make little dumpling purses. Finally, just before serving I added some chopped choy sum for a bit of greenery and textural difference.

Subscribe - It's free!!

Subscribe to get all the latest recipes delivered directly to your inbox.

Leave a comment

23 Comments

  1. Christine August 29, 2012  10:23 am Reply

    I think your photos look fantastic! Especially love the second one with the prepared vegies in the background. Definitely pinning this recipe for later as well - I'm a total mushroom fiend as well... :)

    • Jennifer August 29, 2012  11:07 am Reply

      Thanks Christine :D Hehe I've never thought of myself as a mushroom fiend, but you're right. I totally am :D Glad to see I'm not alone ;)

  2. Sneh | Cook Republic August 29, 2012  12:18 pm Reply

    Love your take on the Donna Hay challenge and I could eat the contents of that bowl for lunch!!

  3. Maureen | Orgasmic Chef August 29, 2012  12:59 pm Reply

    You win, Donna loses in my book. I do want to say that I love her styling and photos but to me, she's not perfection. She has a certain style and she rarely strays from it so we always know when we see a photo if it's hers or not. Your food always comes across as real food that I can envision myself eating.

    Like this bowl of dumplings and broth :)

  4. Aunt Clara August 29, 2012  2:33 pm Reply

    You did a great job, your photo might be identical to the original, but still is very good. And darn if it doesn't look like something I could try about now.

  5. Laura (Tutti Dolci) August 29, 2012  2:37 pm Reply

    I love mushrooms, these dumplings look fantastic! Great job on the photo challenge - personally, I like your styling best :).

  6. Simone August 29, 2012  2:47 pm Reply

    Yay, you participated!! How cool is that... ! Definitely like your try but yes the broth looks a bit different. I struggled as well with the dumplings and I did make pouches which don't exactly look the same and they do disintegrate fairly quickly I found. I love your own styling possibly more then the original! Glad you liked the recipe too as I thought it was delicious! So glad you joined in this month Jennifer!

  7. Rosa August 29, 2012  4:27 pm Reply

    A wonderful dish! This broth looks amazing. beautiful pictures too. Great job!

    Cheers,

    Rosa

  8. Daisy@Nevertoosweet August 29, 2012  10:40 pm Reply

    Looks lovely ;) Very healthy too hehe ~ great recipe thanks for sharing!

  9. Mushrooms Canada August 29, 2012  11:49 pm Reply

    Your recreation of this Mushroom Dumplings with Ginger and Shiitake Broth is absolutely perfect in my books! I love your idea of making dumpling "purses" for bite-size enjoyment, I'd probably have to do the same if I ever want dinner guests again. Well done and thanks for sharing!

    -Shannon



  10. Kankana August 30, 2012  5:53 am Reply

    I tried so much to photo shoot this soup but it was hard and finally I gave up! Your looks very neat and pretty close to the original.

  11. Tina @ bitemeshowme August 30, 2012  8:07 am Reply

    Wow, just wow. What a ripper of a dish - it looks like that perfect winter warmer. I see myself having a large bowl of this, sitting in front of the telly all rugged up in my pjs. Oh it looks perfect... and I love the sound of the broth - ginger and shiitake go so well together.

  12. Johanna GGG August 30, 2012  10:13 pm Reply

    Interesting to see these different recipes. I agree that I prefer your final photo - partly because I am not a huge fan of Donna Hay's style and partly because I think it is obviously a style you are so much more comfortable with - I really like your photos and I think the idea of copying someone else's to learn is useful but in the end great photos will have your own style

  13. Jenn August 31, 2012  5:09 pm Reply

    Oooh I very much like your styled version! The chopped ingredients in the back help tell the store of the dish being made. Those mushrooms are beautiful!

  14. Jen Laceda @ Tartine and Apron Strings September 1, 2012  4:03 pm Reply

    Jen, these are lovely photos!!! You make me want to reach out inside my screen and have a sip of that hot broth! Mouthwatering! Since we're going into autumn in our neck of the woods, this is a perfect dish for those chilly nights :)



  15. Sylvie @ Gourmande in the Kitchen September 2, 2012  6:06 am Reply

    I like your version very much, I think you did a great job with the challenge. Chris Court is one of my favorite photographers, I really love his work.

  16. Moya September 2, 2012  9:19 pm Reply

    Love the photographs and I think you did a fantastic job, the soup looks so delicious and healthy! :)

  17. Nic@diningwithastud September 5, 2012  1:20 pm Reply

    I def prefer your styling shot :) although both look great Jen!

  18. Minnie@thelady8home September 7, 2012  8:28 am Reply

    I love the pictures, and this recipe is gorgeous. And vegan too!! Awesome!!!! Bookmarked.

  19. bondiwaves September 7, 2012  10:23 pm Reply

    This looks amazing - I can't wait to give it a try! Thanks :-)



  20. Pingback : Feta Cheese with Preserved Lemon and Vanilla Infused Olive Oil and A Photography Challenge | Food and Tools

 

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published.

Rate this recipe:  

 
Pinterest