At the risk of sounding like Scrooge, I don’t like your usual Christmas fare. Fruit mince pies, Christmas cake and plum puddings have never been my thing, and being vegetarian, well that means Christmas hams and turkeys are out too. Shortbread is ok, but it’s not something I choose to eat. Never having liked sultana’s, or dead flies as I like to call them, the thought of Christmas cake is never going to get me excited.
As much as I love Christmas, it’s strange that I don’t actually like traditional Christmas fare. So, I decided, this year I would make a Christmas treat I would actually like. No sultanas, or mixed peel in site….ok, as a compromise, I served them (albiet soaked in alcohol) on the side for the people who like them.
The recipe for this cake comes from delicious Simply The Best, which you might recall I mentioned in my list of favourite cookbooks. At the back of the book is a small section on non-traditional Christmas fare, and when I saw this Christmas Spice Cake it immediately called my name. Ok, I admit, the fact it contained cocoa had something to do with it, along with the fact it didn’t contain dried fruit, but it also sounded intriguing with it’s mix of spices, almonds and polenta.
Calling this a cake is perhaps a bit misleading. It’s somewhat of a cross between a cake and a cookie. It’s dense and crumbly, but not quite as dense as a cookie. But, it’s deliciously different and something I could easily see becoming a new Christmas tradition in our house.
Do you enjoy traditional Christmas fare? What are your favourite festive treats?
PS Don’t forget to check out all of the other delicious submissions to the festive favourites blog hop event below.
- 250g of plain (all purpose) flour, sifted
- 200g of fine polenta
- 140g of blanched almonds, toasted and chopped
- 2 tbs of cocoa, sifted, plus extra to dust
- 200g of caster sugar
- 125g of unsalted butter, chilled and cut into small cubes
- 125ml of oil
- 3 eggs, lightly beaten
- 1 tbs of vanilla extract
- 1½ tsp of ground cinnamon
- ½ tsp of freshly grated nutmeg
- ½ tsp of ground cardamon
- 200g of whole almonds
- Preheat the oven to 180 degrees celsius (355 Fahrenheit) and grease s 24cm loose bottomed tart tin.
- Place the flour, polenta, blanched almonds, cocoa and sugar into the bowl of a food processor fitted with a steel blade and pulse until combined. Add the butter and process until the butter forms fine breadcrumbs.
- Add the oil, eggs, vanilla and spices and pulse until the dough forms a ball.
- Press into the prepared tart tin and bake for 25 minutes or until tested with a cake tester. Cool in the pan for 10 minutes before removing to a wire wrack to cool completely.
- Dust with cocoa before serving and serve with whipped cream and stewed fruits or mascarpone and fresh berries.
This month’s Festive Favourites Blog Hop event is being hosted by JJ from 84th & 3rd. We hope you can join us in this fun exploration of Festive Treats. Check out all of the other Festive Favourites submissions below.

That cake looks amazing!!! I'd love a slice right now...
Cheers,
Rosa
Thanks Rosa! I'd love to share a slice with you :D
This is a beautiful cake .. love how much like a tart it looks!
I love the texture of polenta in baking and I am sure this cake/cookie tastes wonderful. Happy Christmas :)
Thanks Moya, it was a great alternative to fruit cake and I really enjoyed it. Maybe it will become a new tradition :D
wow! The cake looks so rich and delicious!
Hi Anh,
Actually, the cake isn't all that rich. It's dense, but not sickly rich. It's really lovely with some fresh berries and cream, which is how we enjoyed it last night. :)
oh this sounds like a delightful christmas cake that doesn't contain deadflies - hahahaha! It' looks so dense and the spices and cocoa would be delicious, I've a few friends who also dislike christmas cake and mince pies, this will be on the cards next year for those people (seen as this year it's just my man and I - and we both love fruit mince pies) who don't like the fruit. Merry Christmas!
Hehe I'm glad my dead flies comment made you laugh. But sultanas and raisins do look like dead flies :D
The cake is really dense, but not as dense as a biscuit. It's really deliciously different. It's great to enjoy with an afternoon coffee or tea too. And it's a great cake for us this Christmas as it's just my fiance and I this year, so it's something we can slowly nibble on.
Merry Christmas to you too Jas :D
Oh this looks so yummy! I am not a fan of the traditional Christmas cake either :)
That heavy sticky fruitcake that people serve at every party - no thanks! This looks absolutely gorgeous. I have been sticking to mainly spice laced baking this Christmas season too :)
Thanks Amy :D So glad to find someone else who doesn't like Christmas cake either. Spices are just so wonderful to bake with at Christmas time.
mmmm... this looks fantastic!
Yum - this looks so good! Anything with chocolate, almonds and polenta is a winner in my book! Those booze soaked fruits...straight over the top... I'll have yours too ;)
You're welcome to them JJ :D
You are a girl after my own heart. I really dislike dried fruit, sultanas, mixed peel and everything that resembles anything like it.
This looks wonderful. Chocolate and spices is one of my favourite combinations.
Glad to see I am not alone Claire :D
Beautiful cake, Jennifer. And I love the way you've styled this, too.
I love the combination of flavours and spices - this looks positively scrumptious! :D
That cake looks so tempting!! Wish I could have a slice of it right now!! :D
Wow... this looks divine! Would it be wrong to eat straight out of the oven like a cookie? hehe. Tempted to make this for one of my many Christmas events!
Hi Amy, not wrong at all. :D
Merry Christmas!
Also...I love making new traditions for Christmas! Im all for bypassing the traditional desserts and making something delicious :)
I'm afraid that I am a complete sucker for Christmas fare, traditional, or Australian or in the case of my family, Chinese food! :P
Your cake/biscuit is so pretty:) I am intrugued to see what it tastes like, as I have never had a polenta cake before.
It really does taste like a cross between a cake and a biscuit. It's not as light as a cake, but not as dense as a cookie. The polenta gives it a little bit of a crunch. :D
Isn't it interesting that there seems to be quite a few of us who aren't that fond of the fruit filled Christmas cakes and puddings. Love this recipe. Want to make it right now! Thank you for sharing.
Thanks Lizzy :D It is interesting to see so many of us who don't like fruit filled Christmas fare. It makes for a great diversity of desserts in the blog hop too!!!
Merry Christmas to you and your family.
Wow! The cake looks divine! So festive and absolutely delicious! Gorgeous pictures! :)
Thank you so much Baker Street :D
in between a cookie and a cake, best of both worlds! Think the cream completes it :)
Hi Julie,
The cream really does complete it. I think it helps with the denseness (is that even a word?!) of it.
Merry Christmas!
I'm not a fan of Christmas pudding or cake either; I didn't even touch raisin toast until recent years. This cake sounds lovely. I love the aroma of cinnamon and nutmeg, filling the house with that traditional Christmas flavour.
I love the aroma of spices filling the house too Tenille :D Merry Christmas to you and your family.
It does look really delicious and different and spicy. i know i would love it
oooooh polenta, looks so beautiful :)
Thank Muppy :D
I hope you and your family have a wonderful Christmas.
I am so with you on this one. I'll eat mince pies, but other than that I'm just not a fan of anything overloaded with dried fruit. This looks like the perfect alternative - sweet, spiced and chocolatey. Yum.
I have a love/hate relationship with fruit in Christmas baked goodies. Love the look of you spice cake for when I am over the fruit.
Thanks Sara :D
wow, looks really lovely.
Beautiful! I love how crumbly and cookie like it looks inside! And the nutmeg and cardamom sound delicious :)
Thank you so much Heidi. :D Merry Christmas to you! :)
Elegant, decadent...this looks amazing!
Thank you so much Jennifer :D
I hope you have a wonderful Christmas. :)
I seem to have grown into a fondness for a nice, rich fruit cake at Xmas time, but part of my enjoyment is all of the wonderful spices they have have in them.
Being the chocolate tragic that I am, your recipe is even more attractive, though. Quick, spicy and chocolatey - I don't need to know anymore about it, I'm sold.
Hi Amanda,
It really is a lovely and quick cake to make, especially since it's all made in the food processor. It would be easy to adapt to different flavourings too. I think next time I make it though I would add a little more cocoa as I didn't think it was chocolatey enough....but that's just me and I'm a chocolate nut. :D
Hey Jennifer, your Christmas Spice Cake is a Recipe Guessing Game on Knapkins. Think your friends can win? www.knapkins.com/guess_games/1086?source=blog
LOL @ the dead flies. Tahts totally what my mum calls them. Whenever my grandma bakes, mum picks out "the flies" hahahaha. Love the look of this cake Jen! Stunning :)